Contested extractivism: impact assessment, public engagement, and environmental knowledge production in Alaska's Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta
Abstract
For large extractive mineral projects, Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) processes function in part as a procedural tool to adjudicate the legitimacy of divergent environmental truth claims. Successful anti-extraction movements work to litigate divergent knowledge claims in the public arena, but few anti-extraction communities have access to a broad public audience. This article examines the proposed Donlin Gold mine in southwestern Alaska, a locally divisive yet publicly invisible extraction controversy, to understand how communities contest the boundaries of knowledge production and legitimacy set out by EIS procedures without the benefit of broad public awareness. Through a multi-method analysis of the public engagement segment of Donlin's Draft EIS, we find that anti-Donlin activists worked to construct environmental knowledge that drew jointly on claims to local knowledge and scientific expertise through a temporary assemblage of local activists and external consultants. The contested epistemic understandings of residents, expert consultants, and state and federal regulators further reveal the role of regulatory processes in constructing and maintaining boundaries of epistemic legitimacy, while also pointing to emergent possibilities for social action based in locally-situated environmental truth claims.
Key Words: Environmental Impact Statement, mining, truth claims, Donlin Gold mine, AlaskaFull Text:
PDFReferences
Agius, P., T. Jenkin, S. Jarvis, R. Howitt and R. Williams. 2007. (Re)asserting Indigenous rights and jurisdictions within a politics of place: transformative nature of Native title negotiations in South Australia. Geographical Research 45(2): 194–202.
Agyeman, J., D. Schlosberg, L. Craven and C. Matthews. 2016. Trends and directions in environmental justice: From inequity to everyday life, community, and just sustainabilities. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 41(1): 321–340.
Alaska Department of Fish and Game. 2019. Estimated harvests of fish, wildlife, and wild plant resources by Alaska region and census areas, 2017. Division of Subsistence, Alaska Department of Fish and Game. Available from https://www.adfg.alaska.gov/static-sub/CSIS/PDFs/Estimated%20Harvests%20by%20Region%20and%20Census%20Area.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Beck, U. 1997. Global risk politics. Political Quarterly 68(B): 18–33.
Bristol Bay Land Trust. 2013. Citizens alternative Bristol Bay area plan for state lands (CABBAP). May. Available from http://www.bristolbaylandtrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/BBAP_May_final.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Bryant, R.L. 1998. Power, knowledge and political ecology in the third world: a review. Progress in Physical Geography 22(1): 79–94.
Bullard, R.D. 2003. Confronting environmental racism in the 21st century. Race, Poverty and the Environment 10(1): 49–52.
Cannon, D. 2016. Comments from Dave Cannon for the Donlin Gold DEIS. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/Cannon,%20Dave%201.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Cashmore, M. and T. Richardson. 2013. Power and environmental assessment: introduction to the special issue. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 39: 1–4.
Cashmore, M., A. Bond and D. Cobb. 2008. The role and functioning of environmental assessment: Theoretical reflections upon an empirical investigation of causation. Journal of Environmental Management 88(4): 1233–1248.
Cashmore, M., T. Richardson, T. Hilding-Ryedvik, and L. Emmelin. 2010. Evaluating the effectiveness of impact assessment instruments: theorising the nature and implications of their political constitution. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 30(6): 371–379.
Chilton, P. 1987. Metaphor, euphemism and the militarization of language. Current Research on Peace and Violence 10(1): 7–19.
Chilvers, J. 2008(a). Deliberating competence: theoretical and practitioner perspectives on effective participatory appraisal practice. Science, Technology and Human Values 33(2): 155–185.
Chilvers, J. 2008(b). Environmental risk, uncertainty, and participation: mapping an emergent epistemic community. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 40(12): 2990–3008.
Clautice, K. 2016. Donlin Gold EIS comment. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/Clautice,%20Karen%20H.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Cone, M. 2005. Silent snow: The slow poisoning of the Arctic. New York: Grove Press.
Davidov, V. 2014. Land, copper, flora: Dominant materialities and the making of Ecuadorian resource environments. Anthropological Quarterly 87(1): 31–58.
Ecology and Environment, Inc. 2010. An assessment of ecological risk to wild salmon systems from large-scale mining in the Nushagak and Kvichak watersheds of the Bristol Bay Basin. October. The Nature Conservancy. Available from https://www.nature.org/content/dam/tnc/nature/en/documents/ecological-risk-assessment-bristol-bay-alaska.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Epstein, S. 2008. Culture and science/technology: rethinking knowledge, power, materiality, and nature. ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 619(1): 165–182.
Escobar, A. 2010. Postconstructivist political ecologies. In: Redclift, M.R. and G. Woodgate (eds.). The International handbook of environmental sociology. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar. Pp. 91–105.
Foley, P. and K. Hébert. 2013. Alternative regimes of transnational environmental certification: governance, marketization, and place in Alaska's salmon fisheries. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 45(11): 2734–2751.
Forsyth, T.J. 2003. Critical political ecology: the politics of environmental science. London: Routledge.
Forsyth, T.J. 2008. Political ecology and the epistemology of social justice. Geoforum 39(2): 756–764.
Hajer, M.A. 1995. The politics of environmental discourse: ecological modernization and the policy process. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Haraway, D. 1988. Situated knowledges: the science question in feminism and the privilege of partial perspective. Feminist Studies 14(3): 575–599.
Heisler, P. 2016. Request to extend public comment period. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/Center%20for%20Science%20in%20Public%20Participation%201.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Hébert, K. 2016. Chronicle of a disaster foretold: scientific risk assessment, public participation, and the politics of imperilment in Bristol Bay, Alaska. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 22(S1): 108–126.
Hébert, K. and S. Brock. 2017. Counting and counter-mapping: contests over the making of a mining district in Bristol Bay, Alaska. Science as Culture 26(1): 56–87.
Hébert, K. and D. Mincyte. 2014. Self-reliance beyond neoliberalism: rethinking autonomy at the edges of empire. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 32(2): 206–222.
Höhler, S. and R. Ziegler. 2010. Nature's accountability: stocks and stories. Science as Culture 19(4): 417–430.
Holley, E.A. and C. Mitcham. 2016. The Pebble Mine dialogue: a case study in public engagement and the social license to operate. Resources Policy 47: 18–27.
Horowitz L.S., A. Keeling, F. Lévesque, T. Rodon, S. Schott and S. Thériault. 2018. Indigenous peoples' relationships to large-scale mining in post/colonial contexts: Toward multidisciplinary comparative perspectives. The Extractive Industries and Society 5(3): 404–414.
Howe, L. and S. Martin. 2009. Arctic-Yukon-Kuskokwim Region. MPRA Paper. Munich: MPRA Paper. Available from https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/33575/1/MPRA_paper_33575.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Howitt, R. 2012. Sustainable indigenous futures in remote Indigenous areas: relationships, processes and failed state approaches. GeoJournal 77: 817-828.
Howitt, R., K. Doohan, S. Suchet-Pearson, S. Cross, R. Lawrence, G.J. Lunkapis, S. Muller, S. Prout and S. Veland. 2013. Intercultural capacity deficits: contested geographies of coexistence in natural resource management. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 54(2):126–40.
Irwin, A. and M. Michael. 2003. Science, social theory, and public knowledge. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
Law, J. and S. Joks. 2019. Indigeneity, science, and difference: notes on the politics of how. Science, Technology and Human Values 44(3): 424–447.
Lewis, T. and J. Owley. 2014. Symbolic politics for disempowered communities: state environmental justice policies. BYU Journal of Public Law 29(1): 183–240.
National Research Council. 2008. Public participation in environmental assessment and decision making. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Nushagak-Mulchatna Watershed Council. 2007. Nushagak River watershed traditional use area conservation plan. November. Available from https://www.nature.org/content/dam/tnc/nature/en/documents/nushagak-river-watershed-traditional-use-area-conservation-plan.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Nushagak-Mulchatna Watershed Council. 2011. Standards and practices for environmentally responsible mining in the Nushagak River watershed. Available from https://akmininginfo.files.wordpress.com/2012/09/a-framework-for-responsible-mining-in-the-nushagak-river-watershed2.pdf (accessed 7 October 2020)
Overland, J.E., M. Wang, J.E. Walsh and J.C. Stroeve. 2014. Future Arctic climate changes: adaptation and mitigation time scales. Earth's Future 2(2): 68–74.
Owens, S. and R. Cowell. 2011. Land and limits: Interpreting sustainability in the planning process. London: Routledge.
Panikkar, B., B. Lemmond, B. Else and M. Murray. 2018. Ice over troubled waters: navigating the Northwest passage using Inuit knowledge and scientific information. Climate Research 75(1):81–94.
Panikkar, B. and J. Tollefson. 2018. Land as material, knowledge and relationships: resource extraction and subsistence imaginaries in Bristol Bay, Alaska. Social Studies of Science 48(5): 715–739.
Pellow, D.N. 2007. Resisting global toxics: transnational movements for environmental justice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Pellow, D.N. 2017. What is critical environmental justice? London: Wiley.
Porter, M.E. and C. van der Linde. 1995. Toward a new conception of the environment-competitiveness relationship. Journal of Economic Perspectives 9(4): 97–118.
Richardson, T. 2005. Environmental assessment and planning theory: four short stories about power, multiple rationality, and ethics. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 25(4): 341–365.
Richardson, T. and G. Weszkalnys. 2014. Introduction: resource materialities. Anthropological Quarterly 87(1): 5–30.
Rose, N. 1999. Powers of freedom: reframing political thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sale, R. and E. Potapov. 2010. The scramble for the Arctic: ownership, exploitation and conflict in the Far North. London: Francis Lincoln Ltd.
Scott, J.C. 1998. Seeing like a state: How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Shavelson, B. 2016. Donlin EIS comments. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/Cook%20Inletkeeper.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Simandan, D. 2019. Revisiting positionality and the thesis of situated knowledge. Dialogues in Human Geography 9(2): 129–149.
Sletto, B. 2009. Special issue: Indigenous cartographies. Cultural Geographies 16(2): 147–152.
Spaeder, J.J. 2005. Co-management in a landscape of resistance: the political ecology of wildlife management in western Alaska. Canadian Anthropology Society 47(2): 165–178.
SRK Consulting. 2016. Plan of operations project description: Donlin Gold project. December. Available from http://dnr.alaska.gov/mlw/mining/largemine/donlin/pdf/poo.description.pdf (accessed 10 October 2020)
Stevenson, M.G. 1996. Indigenous knowledge in environmental assessment. ARCTIC 49(3): 278–291.
Stroeve, J., M.M. Holland, W. Meier, T. Scambos and M. Serreze. 2007. Arctic sea ice decline: faster than forecast. Geophysical Research Letters 34(9).
Teodoro, M.P., M. Haider, and D. Switzer. 2018. U.S. Environmental policy implementation on tribal lands: trust, neglect, and justice. Policy Studies Journal 46(1): 37–59.
Thornton, J. 2016. Donlin Gold petition. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/Alaska%20Community%20Action%20on%20Toxics%203.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Thorpe, L. 2016. Donlin Gold DEIS comments. US Army Corps of Engineers. Available from http://www.donlingoldeis.com/Documents/Draft%20EIS%20Comments/BLM.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)
Vanclay, F. 2020. Reflections on Social Impact Assessment in the 21st century. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 38(2): 126-131.
Vanclay F. and P. Hanna. 2019. Conceptualising company response to community protest: principles to achieve a social license to operate. Land 8(6): 101.
Whitney, K. 2019. It's about time: Adaptive resource management, environmental governance, and science studies. Science, Technology and Human Values 44(2): 263–290.
Young, A. 2019. Donna Haraway on staying with the trouble. For the Wild 131. Available from https://forthewild.world/listen/donna-haraway-on-staying-with-the-trouble-131 (accessed 28 July 2020)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23828
