The strategy of shifting cultivators in West Kalimantan in adapting to the market economy: empirical evidence behind gaps in interdisciplinary communication
Abstract
Issues of climate change and expansion of large-scale land acquisition for industrial plantations continue to ravage the shifting cultivation system that 300–500 million subsistence farmer households depend on. In Indonesia, particularly in Kalimantan and Sumatera, village communities continue to practice shifting cultivation amidst the conversion of lands into industrial plantations. The rampant conversion of farmer's land by large scale companies based in the market economy has resulted in the decline of the shifting cultivation system, and compelled them to enter commercial production. I employed qualitative methods, conducting in-depth interviews and observations in West Kalimantan in 2018. Shifting cultivation today is not just for subsistence, but it is also a strategy to maintain claims to land that has been handed over to companies. Concurrently, people have been developing community plantations using industrial commodities such as rubber and oil palm, which still incorporate subsistence features. The changes occurring in villages have led to conflict since land availability has reduced, while the alternative of working for forestry and plantation companies is hampered by their lack of skills and knowledge. Theoretically, this study indicates the need for communication and synergy between the perspectives of political ecology and cultural ecology in order to understand the socio-politico-economic complexities haunting the village community's alterations in subsistence strategies. The practical implications are that land-based village development should open up communication among stakeholders and position village communities as the key beneficiary in the long run.
Keywords: Shifting cultivation, land conversion, adaptation strategy, market economy, political ecology, Kalimantan, Indonesia
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Abid, M., J. Scheffran, U.A. Schneider and M. Ashfaq. 2015. Farmers' perceptions of and adaptation strategies to climate change and their determinants: the case of Punjab Province, Pakistan. Earth System Dynamics 6: 225–243.
Abu-Lughod, L. 1990. The romance of resistance: tracing transformations of power through Bedouin women. American Ethnologist 7(1): 41-55.
Acciaioli, G.L. and D. Oetami. 2016. Opposition to oil palm plantations in Kalimantan: divergent strategies, convergent outcomes. In R. Cramb and J. McCarthy (eds.). The oil palm complex: smallholders, agribusiness and the state in Indonesia and Malaysia. Singapore: NUS Press. Pp. 327-353.
Almalki, S. 2016. Integrating quantitative and qualitative data in mixed methods research—challenges and benefits. Journal of Education and Learning 5(3): 288-296.
Anonymous. 2017. BPS-Statistic of Ketapang Regency 2017. Ketapang: BPS-Statistic Ketapang Regency.
Archibald, M.M., A.I. Radil, X. Zhang and W.E. Hanson. 2015. Current mixed methods practices in qualitative research: a content analysis of leading journals. International Journal of Qualitative Methods 14(2): 5–33.
Barber, M., S. Jackson, J. Dambacher and M. Finn. 2015. The persistence of subsistence: qualitative social-ecological modeling of Indigenous aquatic hunting and gathering in tropical Australia. Ecology and Society 20(1).
Benjaminsen, T.A. and H. Svarstad. 2019. Political ecology. In Fath, B. (ed.). Encyclopedia of ecology. Vol. 4. Elsevier. Pp. 391-396.
Bissonnette, J.F. and R.D. Koninck. 2015. Large plantations versus smallholdings in Southeast Asia: historical and contemporary trends. Presented at Land grabbing, conflict and agrarian-environmental transformations: perspectives from East and Southeast Asia. Chiang Mai.
Brown, D. and K. Schreckenberg. 1998. Shifting cultivators as agents of deforestation: assessing the evidence. Natural Resource Perspectives No. 29. London: ODI.
Bullinger, C. and M. Haug. 2012. In and out of the forest: decentralisation and recentralisation of forest governance in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies / Österreichische Zeitschrift Für Südostasienwissenschaften 5: 243–262.
Chan, N. and S. Takeda. 2016. The transition away from swidden agriculture and trends in biomass accumulation in fallow forests: case studies in the Southern Chin Hills of Myanmar. Mountain Research and Development 36(3): 320–331.
Choocharoen, C., A. Neef, P. Preechapanya and V. Hoffmann. 2014. Agrosilvopastoral systems in Northern Thailand and Northern Laos: minority peoples' knowledge versus government policy. Land 3(2): 414–436.
Connolly, C. 2017. "Bird cages and boiling pots for potential diseases": contested ecologies of urban 'Swiftlet farming' in George Town, Malaysia. Journal of Political Ecology 24: 24-43.
Creswell, J.W. 2013. Quantitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Dove, M.R. 2015. The view of swidden agriculture, by the early naturalists Linnaeus and Wallace. In M.F. Cairn (ed.). Shifting cultivation and environmental change: indigenous people, agriculture and forest conservation. London: Earthscan. Pp. 3-24.
Dressler, W.H., D. Wilson, J. Clendenning, R. Cramb, R. Keenan, S. Mahanty, T.B. Bruun, O. Mertz and R.D. Lasco. 2017. The impact of swidden decline on livelihoods and ecosystem services in Southeast Asia: a review of the evidence from 1990 to 2015. Ambio 46(3): 291–310.
Elmhirst, R., M. Siscawati, B.S. Basnett and D. Ekowati. 2017. Gender and generation in engagements with oil palm in East Kalimantan, Indonesia: insights from feminist political ecology. The Journal of Peasant Studies. 44(6): 1135-1157.
Friedmann, H. 2015. Governing land and landscapes: political ecology of enclosures and commons. Canadian Food Studies / La Revue Canadienne Des Études Sur l'alimentation 2(2): 23-31.
Geertz, C. 2016[1963]. Involusi Pertanian: proses perubahan ekologi di Indonesia. Jakarta: Komunitas Bambu.
Gönner, C. 2007. Surfing on waves of opportunities: resilient livelihood strategies of Dayak Benuaq Forest users in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. Society and Natural Resources 24(2): 165-173.
Islam, D. and F. Berkes. 2016. Can small-scale commercial and subsistence fisheries co-exist? lessons from an indigenous community in Northern Manitoba, Canada. Maritime Studies 15: 1.
Kingwell-Banham, E. and D.Q. Fuller. 2012. Shifting cultivators in South Asia: expansion, marginalisation and specialisation over the long term. Quaternary International 249: 84–95.
Li, P. and Z. Feng. 2016. Extent and area of swidden in montane mainland Southeast Asia: estimation by multi-step thresholds with Landsat-8 OLI data. Remote Sensing 8(1): 1–17.
Li, P., Z. Feng, L. Jiang, C. Liao and J. Zhang. 2014. A review of swidden agriculture in Southeast Asia. Remote Sensing 6 (2): 1654–1683.
Li, T.M. 2015. Social impacts of oil palm in Indonesia: a gendered perspective from West Kalimantan. Occasional Paper 124. Bogor, Indonesia: CIFOR.
https://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/OccPapers/OP-124.pdf
Li, T.M. 2016. Ketergurusan antargenerasi di zona perkebunan kelapa sawit di Indonesia. Jurnal Analisis Sosial |20(1 & 2): 43-72.
Maharani, C., M. Moeliono, G. Wong, M. Brockhaus, R. Carmenta and M. Kallio. 2019. Development and equity: A gendered inquiry in a swidden landscape. Forest Policy and Economics 101: 120-128.
Maring, P. 2015. Culture of control versus the culture of resistance in the case of control of forest. Makara Human Behavior Studies in Asia 19(1): 27–38.
Mathevet, R., N.L. Peluso, A. Couespel and P. Robbins. 2015. Using historical political ecology to understand the present: water, reeds, and biodiversity in the Camargue Biosphere Reserve, Southern France. Ecology and Society 20(4).
McCarthy, J.F. 2010. Processes of inclusion and adverse incorporation: oil palm and agrarian change in Sumatra, Indonesia. The Journal of Peasant Studies 37(4): 821-850.
McCullough, C. 2019. Review of 'Agricultural involution: the processes of ecological change in Indonesia' by Clifford Geertz. International Journal of Anthropology and Ethnology 3(1).
Meilasari-Sugiana, A. 2018. Oil palm companies, privatization and social dissonance: towards a socially viable and ecologically sustainable land reform in Tanah Laut Regency, South Kalimantan, Indonesia. Journal of Political Ecology 27: 548-468.
Mertz, O. and T.B. Bruun. 2017. Shifting cultivation policies in Southeast Asia: a need to work with rather than against, smallholder farmers. In M. Cairns (ed.). Shifting cultivation policies: balancing environmental and social sustainability. Wallingford: CABI. Pp. 27-42.
Minardi, A. and P.I. Maulani. 2019. Implementation of Indonesia's foreign investment policy in the development of Japan foreign direct investment in Indonesia. Presented at ICASI 2019, July 18-19, Banda Aceh, Indonesia. https://eudl.eu/pdf/10.4108/eai.18-7-2019.2288642.
Nassaji, H. 2015. Qualitative and descriptive research: data type versus data analysis. Language Teaching Research 19 (2): 129–132.
Ndamani, F. and T. Watanabe. 2015. Farmers' perceptions about adaptation practices to climate change and barriers to adaptation: a micro-level study in Ghana. Water 7(9): 4593–4604.
Newby, J., R. Cramb and S. Sakanphet. 2014. Forest transitions and rural livelihoods: multiple pathways of smallholder teak expansion in Northern Laos. Land 3(2): 482–503.
Nugraha, A. and Tim. 2018. Hasil identifikasi dan pengelolaan masyarakat di dalam dan sekitar konsesi perusahaan di Kabupaten Ketapang, Kalimantan Barat. Jakarta: Wana Aksara Institute.
Nygren, A. and S. Rikoon. 2008. Political ecology revisited: integration of politics and ecology does matter. Society and Natural Resources 21(9): 767-782.
Olayemi, B. and D. Nirmala. 2016. Creating economic viability in rural South Africa through water resource management in subsistence farming. Environmental Economics 7(4): 68–77.
Olsson, L. and A. Jerneck. 2010. Farmers fighting climate change-from victims to agents in subsistence livelihoods. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 1 (3): 363–373.
Palupi, S., Y.S. Sukapti, S. Maemunah, P. Prasetyohadi and A. Tømte. 2017. Privatisasi transmigrasi dan kemitraan plama menopang industri sawit: resiko hak asasi manusia dalam kebijakan transmigrasi dan kemitraan plasma di sektor industri perkebunan sawit. Jakarta: The Institute for Ecosoc Rights and Norwegian Center for Human Rights (NCHR).
Peluso, N.L. 2005. Seeing property in land use: local territorializations in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Geografisk Tidsskrift, Danish Journal of Geography 105(1): 1-15.
Peluso, N.L. 1992. Rich forests, poor people: resource control and resistance in Java. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Penot, E. 2007. From shifting cultivation to sustainable jungle rubber: a history of innovations in Indonesia. In M. Cairns (ed.). Voices from the forest: integrating indigenous knowledge into sustainable upland farming. Washington : RFF Press. Pp. 577-599.
Peterson, G. 2000. Political ecology and ecological resilience: an integration of human and ecological dynamics. Ecological Economics 35: 323–336.
Petrenko, C., J. Paltseva and S. Searle. 2016. Ecological impacts of palm oil expansion in Indonesia. White Paper. Washington DC: International Council on Clean Transportation.
https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/Indonesia-palm-oil-expansion_ICCT_july2016.pdf.
Quandt, A. 2016. Towards integrating political ecology into resilience-based resource management. Resources 5(4): 31.
Rahman, S.A., J.B. Jacobsen, J.R. Healey, J.M. Roshetko and T. Sunderland. 2017. Finding alternatives to swidden agriculture: does agroforestry improve livelihood options and reduce pressure on existing forest? Agroforestry Systems 91(1): 185–199.
Ribolzi, O., O. Evrard, S. Huon, A.D. Rouw, N. Silvera, K.O. Latsachack, B. Soulileuth, R. Lefèvre, A. Pierret, G. Lacombe, O. Sengtaheuanghoung and C. Valentin. 2017. From shifting cultivation to teak plantation: effect on overland flow and sediment yield in a montane tropical catchment. Scientific Reports 7(1).
Ring, M.S. 2020. SandLife and the death of dunes: political ecology discourses from conservation to restoration in Haverdal, Sweden. Journal of Political Ecology 27: 67–83.
Rösler, M. 1997. Shifting cultivation in the Ituri Forest [Haut-Zaïre]. Civilisations 44: 44–61.
Santika, T., K.A. Wilson, E. Meijaard, S. Budiharta, E.E. Law, M. Sabri, M. Struebig, M. Ancrenaz and T.M. Poh. 2019. Changing landscapes, livelihoods and village welfare in the context of oil palm development. Land Use Policy 87: 104073
Saqib, E.S., J.K.M. Kuwornu, S. Panezia and U. Ali. 2018. Factors determining subsistence farmers' access to agricultural credit in flood-prone areas of Pakistan. Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences 39(2): 262–268.
Scott, J.C. 1976. The moral economy of the peasant: subsistence and rebellion in Southeast Asia. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Scott, J.C. 1985. Weapon of the weak: everyday forms of peasant resistance. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Scott, J.C. 1992. Domination and the arts of resistance: hidden transcripts. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Setyowati, A.B. 2020. Governing the ungovernable: contesting and reworking REDD+ in Indonesia. Journal of Political Ecology. 27: 456-475.
Siahaya, M.E., T.R. Hutauruk, H.S.E.S. Aponno, J.W. Hatulesila, and A.B. Mardhanie. 2016. Traditional ecological knowledge on shifting cultivation and forest management in East Borneo, Indonesia. International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services and Management 12(1–2): 14–23.
Sima, M., E.A. Popovici, D. Bălteanu, D.M. Micu, G. Kucsicsa, C. Dragotă and I. Grigorescu. 2015. A farmer-based analysis of climate change adaptation options of agriculture in the Bărăgan Plain, Romania. Earth Perspectives 2(5).
Sirait, M. 2009. Indigenous peoples and oil palm plantation expansion in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Working Papers b16385. Nairobi: World Agroforestry Centre. http://apps.worldagroforestry.org/downloads/Publications/PDFS/RP16385.pdf
Srivastava, A. and S.B. Thomson. 2009. Framework analysis: research note. Journal of Administration and Governance 4(2): 72–79.
Sulistyawati, E., I.R. Noble and M.L. Roderick. 2005. A simulation model to study land use strategies in swidden agriculture systems. Agricultural Systems 85(3): 271–288.
Terauchi, D., N. Imang, M. Nanang, M. Kawai, M.A. Sardjono, F. Pambudhi and M. Inoue. 2014. Implication for designing a REDD+ program in a frontier of oil palm plantation development: evidence in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. Open Journal of Forestry 4(3): 259–277.
Thaler, G.M. and C.A.M. Anandi. 2017. Shifting cultivation, contentious land change and forest governance: the politics of swidden in East Kalimantan. The Journal of Peasant Studies 44(5): 1066–1087.
Thung, P. H. 2018. A case study on the persistence of swidden agriculture in the context of post-2015 anti-haze regulation in West-Kalimantan. Human Ecology 46: 197–205.
Toumbourou, T.D. and W.H. Dressler. 2020. Sustaining livelihoods in a palm oil enclave: differentiated gendered responses in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. Asia Pacific Viewpoint https://doi.org/10.1111/apv.12265
Vayda, A.P. 1983. Progressive contextualization: methods for research in human ecology. Human Ecology 11: 265-281.
Vos, E.D. 2013. Palm oil land disputes in West Kalimantan: the politics of scale in processes of dispute resolution. An empirical research on dispute resolution strategies in Sambas District. MSc thesis. Wageningen University and Research Center.
Wibowo, L.R., I. Hakim, H. Komarudin, D.R. Kurniasari, D. Wicaksono and B. Okarda. 2019. Penyelesaian tenurial perkebunan kelapa sawit di kawasan hutan untuk kepastian investasi dan keadilan. Bogor: CIFOR.
https://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/WPapers/WP247Wibowo.pdf.
Willow, A.J. and S. Wylie. 2014. Politics, ecology, and the new anthropology of energy: exploring the emerging frontiers of hydraulic fracking. Journal of Political Ecology 21 (1): 222–236.
Zanotti, L., C. Carothers, C.A. Apok, S. Huang, J. Coleman and C. Ambrozek. 2020. Political ecology and decolonial research: co-production with the Iñupiat in Utqiaġvik. Journal of Political Ecology 27: 43–66.
Zimmerer, K.S. and T.J. Bassett. 2003. Approaching political ecology: society, nature, and scale in human-environment studies. In K.S. Zimmerer and T.J. Bassett (eds.). Political ecology: an integrative approach to geography and environment - development studies. New York: Guilford Press. Pp. 1-25.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23757
