From paper to practice? Assembling a rights-based conservation approach
Abstract
Drawing on a collaborative ethnographic study of the 2016 International Union for the Conservation of Nature World Conservation Congress (WCC), we analyze how Indigenous peoples and local community (IPLC) rights advocates have used a rights-based approach (RBA) to advance long-standing struggles to secure local communities' land and resource rights and advance governing authority in biodiversity conservation. The RBA has allowed IPLC advocates to draw legitimacy from the United Nations system—from its declarations to its special rapporteurs—and to build transnational strategic alliances in ways they could not with participatory discourses. Using it, they have brought attention to biodiversity as a basic human right and to the struggle to use, access, and own it as a human rights struggle. In this article, we show how the 2016 WCC provided a platform for building and reinforcing these alliances, advancing diverse procedural and substantive rights, redefining key principles and standards for a rights-based conservation approach, and leveraging international support for enforcement mechanisms on-the-ground. We argue that, as advocates staked out physical and discursive space at the venue, they secured the authority to shape conservation politics, shifting the terrain of struggle between strict conservationists and community activists and creating new conditions of possibility for advancing the human rights agenda in international conservation politics. Nonetheless, while RBAs have been politically successful at reconfiguring global discourse, numerous obstacles remain in translating that progress to secure human rights to resources "on the ground", and it is vital that the international conservation community finance the implementation of RBA in specific locales, demand that nation states create monitoring and grievance systems, and decolonize the ways in which they interact with IPLCs. Finally, we reflect on the value of the Collaborative Event Ethnography methodology, with its emphasis on capturing the mundane, meaningful and processual aspects of policymaking, in illuminating the on-going labor entailed in bringing together and aligning the disparate elements in dynamic assemblages.
Keywords: Human rights, global conservation governance, collaborative event ethnography, Indigenous peoples
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Adams, W.M. and D. Hulme. 2001a. Changing narratives, policies and practices in African conservation. In D. Hulme and M. Murphree (eds.). African wildlife and livelihoods. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Adams, W.M. and D. Hulme. 2001b. If community conservation is the answer in Africa, what is the question? Oryx 35(3): 193-200.
Agrawal, A. and C.C. Gibson. 1999. Enchantment and disenchantment: the role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development 27(4): 629-649.
Agrawal, A. and K. Redford. 2009. Conservation and displacement: an overview. Conservation and Society 7(10): 1-10.
Alcorn, J.B. and A.G. Royo. 2007. Conservation's engagement with human rights: "traction", "slippage", or avoidance?" Policy Matters 15: 115-133.
Alpert, P. 1996. Integrated conservation and development projects. BioScience 46(11): 845-855.
Anand, P. 2007. Right to water and access to water: an assessment. Journal of International Development 19(4): 511-526.
Anderson, M.D. 2008. Rights-based food systems and the goals of food systems reform. Agriculture and Human Values 25(1): 593.
Ayers, A., J.N. Kittinger and M.B. Vaughan. 2018. Whose right to manage? Distribution of property rights affects equity and power dynamics in comanagement. Ecology and Society 23(2): 30-49.
Baer, M. and A. Gerlak. 2015. Implementing the human right to water and sanitation: a study of global and local discourses. Third World Quarterly 36(8): 1527-1545.
Bakker, K. 2007. The 'commons' versus the 'commodity': alter-globalization, anti-privatization and the human right to water in the Global South. Antipode 39(3): 430-455.
Banisar, D., S. Parmar, L. de Silva and C. Excell. 2012. Moving from principles to rights: Rio 2012 and access to information, public participation, and justice. Sustainable Development Law and Policy 12(3): 8-66.
Bedi, H.P. 2015. Right to food, right to mine? Competing human rights claims in Bangladesh. Geoforum 59: 248-257.
Berkes, F. 2004. Rethinking community-based conservation. Conservation Biology 18(3): 621-630.
Borrini-Feyerabend, G., and A. Kothari. 2008. Recognising and supporting indigenous and community conservation: Ideas and experiences from the grassroots. Briefing Note 9. IUCN CEESP/WCPA
Brockington, D. and J. Igoe. 2006. Eviction for conservation: a global overview. Conservation and Society 4(3): 424-470.
Brosius, J.P. 2004. Indigenous Peoples and protected areas at the World Parks Congress. Conservation Biology 18(3): 609-612.
Brosius, J.P. and L. Campbell. 2010. Collaborative event ethnography: Conservation and development trade-offs at the fourth World Conservation Congress. Conservation and Society 8(4): 245-255.
Brosius, J.P. and D. Russell. 2003. Conservation from above: an anthropological perspective on transboundary protected areas and ecoregional planning. Journal of Sustainable Forestry 17(1/2): 39-65.
Brosius, J.P., A.L. Tsing and C. Zerner. 1998. Representing communities: Histories and politics of community-based natural resource management. Society and Natural Resources 11(2): 157-168.
Brown, C., P. Neves-Silva, and L. Heller. 2016. The human right to water and sanitation: a new perspective for public policies. Ciencia and Saude Coletiva 21(3): 661-670.
Campbell, L.M., C. Corson, N.J. Gray, K.I. MacDonald and J.P. Brosius. 2014. Studying global environmental meetings to understand global environmental governance: Collaborative event ethnography of the 10th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity. Global Environmental Politics 14(3): 1-20.
Chapin, M. 2004. A challenge to conservationists. World Watch 17(6): 17-30.
Choy, T.K., L. Faier, M.J. Hathaway, M. Inoue, S. Satsuka and A. Tsing. 2009a. A new form of collaboration in cultural anthropology: Matsutake worlds. American Ethnologist 36(2): 380-403.
Choy, T.K., L. Faier, M.J. Hathaway, M. Inoue, S. Satsuka and A. Tsing. 2009b. Strong collaboration as a method for multi-sited ethnography: on mycorrhizal relations. In M.-A. Falzon (ed.). Multi-sited ethnography: theory, praxis and locality in contemporary research. New York: Routledge. Pp. 197-214.
Clark, C. 2017. Of what use is a deradicalized human right to water? Human Rights Law Review 17(2): 231-260.
Colchester, M., M.F. Ferrari, J. Nelson, C. Kidd, P. Zaninka, M. Venant, L. Regpala, G.T. Balawag, B. Motin and B. Lasimbang. 2008. Conservation and Indigenous Peoples: assessing the progress since Durban. FPP Series on Forest Peoples and Protected Areas. Forest Peoples Programme.
Cooney, R. and Aspensperg-Traun. 2013. Raising local community voices: CITES, livelihoods and sustainable use. Review of European Community and International Environmental Law 22(3): 301-310.
Correia, J.E. 2018a. Adjudication and its aftereffects in three Inter-American court cases brought against Paraguay: Indigenous land rights. Erasmus Law Review 11(1): 43-56.
Correia, J.E. 2018b. Indigenous rights at a crossroads: territorial struggles, the Inter-American court of human rights, and legal geographies of liminality. Geoforum 97: 73-83.
Corson, C., S. Brady, A. Zuber, J. Lord and A. Kim. 2015. The right to resist: subordinating civil society at Rio+20. The Journal of Peasant Studies 42(3): 859-878.
Corson, C., L.M. Campbell and K.I. MacDonald. 2014. Capturing the personal in politics: ethnographies of global environmental governance. Global Environmental Politics 14(3): 21-40.
Corson, C., N.L. Gray, L.M. Campbell and P. Wilshusen. 2019. Assembling global conservation governance. Geoforum 103: 56-65.
Corson, C., R.L. Gruby, R. Witter, S. Hagerman, D. Suarez, S. Greenberg, M. Bourque, N.J. Gray and L.M. Campbell. 2014. Everyone's solution? Defining and re-defining protected areas in the Convention on Biological Diversity. Conservation and Society 12(2): 71-83.
DeGeorges, P.A. and B.K. Reilly. 2009. The realities of community based natural resource management and biodiversity conservation in sub-Saharan Africa. Sustainability 1(3): 734-788.
Domínguez, L. and C. Luoma. 2020. Decolonising conservation policy: How colonial land and conservation ideologies persist and perpetuate indigenous injustices at the expense of the environment. Land 6(65).
Doolittle, A.A. 2010. The politics of indigeneity: Indigenous strategies for inclusion in climate change negotiations. Conservation and Society 8(4): 286-291.
Duffy, R. 2010. Nature crime: how we're getting conservation wrong. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Duffy, R. 2014. Waging a war to save biodiversity: the rise of militarized conservation. International Affairs 90(4): 819-824.
Edelman, M. and C. James. 2011. Peasants' rights and the UN system: Quixotic struggle? Or emancipatory idea whose time has come? The Journal of Peasant Studies 38(1): 81-108.
Erickson, K. and D. Stull. 1998. Doing team ethnography: warnings and advice. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Ferguson, J. and A. Gupta. 2002. Spatializing states: toward an ethnography of neoliberal governmentality. American Ethnologist 29(4): 981-1002.
Franco, J.C., L. Mehta and G.J. Veldwisch. 2013. The global politics of water grabbing. Third World Quarterly 34(9): 1651-1675.
Golay, C. and I. Biglino. 2013. Human rights responses to land grabbing: a right to food perspective. Third World Quarterly 34(9): 1630-1650.
Gray, N., C. Corson, L.M. Campbell, P. Wilshusen, R. Gruby and S. Hagerman. 2019. Doing strong collaborative fieldwork in human geography. Geographical Review. https://doi.org/10.1111/gere.12352
Gray, N.J. 2010. Sea change: exploring the international effort to promote marine protected areas. Conservation and Society 8(4): 331-338.
Greiber, T., M. Janki, M. Orellana, A. Savaresi and D.L. Shelton. 2013. Conservation with justice: a rights-based approach. Environmental Law and Policy Paper 71. Gland: International Union for Conservation of Nature.
Haglund, L. and R. Stryker. 2015. Introduction: making sense of the multiple and complex pathways by which human rights are realized. In Closing the rights gap: from human rights to social transformation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Harris, L.M., L. Rodina and C. Morinville. 2015. Revisiting the human right to water from an enironmental justice lens. Politics, Groups, and Identities 3(4): 660-665.
IUCN. 1980. World conservation strategy: living resource conservation for sustainable development. Gland, Switzerland: Prepared by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources with the advice, cooperation and financial assistance of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) and in Collaboration with the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).
IUCN. 2014. About the IUCN World Conservation Congress. Accessed July 10. http://www.iucnworldconservationcongress.org/about/
IUCN. 2017. About IUCN. International Union for Conservation of Nature, accessed October 11. https://www.iucn.org/about
IUCN. 2019. Advancing governance and rights in global conservation action 2017-2020 programme strategy update. Gland: IUCN Global Programme on Governance and Rights.
Johnson, C. and T.J. Forsyth. 2002. In the eyes of the state: negotiating a rights-based approach to forest conservation in Thailand. World Development 30(9): 1591-1605.
Kashwan, P. 2013. The politics of rights-based approaches in conservation. Land Use Policy 31: 613-626.
Knox, J.H. 2017. Report of the special rapporteur on the issue of human rights obligations relating to the enjoyment of a safe, clean, healthy and sustainable environment. United Nations, Human Rights Council.
Kothari, A. 2001. Time to move out of Africa! – a response to Adams and Hulme. Oryx 35(3): 204-205.
Kothari, A., P. Camill and J. Brown. 2013. Conservation as if people also mattered: Policy and practice of community-based conservation. Conservation and Society 11(1): 1-15. doi: 10.4103/0972-4923.110937.
Koutouki, K. 2018. A rights-based approach to indigenous women and gender inequalities in resource development in northern Canada. Review of European Comparative and International Environmental Law 27(1): 63-74.
Kowal, E. 2015. Welcome to country: acknowledgement, belonging and white anti-racism. Cultural Studies Review 21(2): 173-204.
Künnemann, R. and S.M. Suárez. 2013. International human rights and governing land grabbing: a view from global civil society. Globalizations 10(1): 123-139.
Lador, Y. 2007. Human rights - a new "territory" for nature conservation organizations. Policy Matters: Conservation and Human Rights 15: 53-56.
Larson, A.M. and J. Springer. 2016. Recognition and respect for tenure rights. Natural Resource Governance Framework Conceptual Paper. Gland, Switzerland: International Union for Conservation of Nature, Commission on Environmental, Economic and Social Policy and the Center for International Forestry Research.
Li, T.M. 2002. Engaging simplifications: Community-based resource management, market processes and state agendas in upland southeast Asia. World Development 30(2): 265-283.
Li, T. 2007. Practices of assemblage and community forest management. Economy and Society 36(2): 263-293.
Lunstrum, E. 2014. Green militarization: anti-poaching efforts and the spatial contours of Kruger national park. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 104(4): 816-832.
MacDonald, K.I. 2010. Business, biodiversity and "new fields" of conservation: the World Conservation Congress and the renegotiation of organizational order. Conservation and Society 8(4): 256-275.
Manzo, K. 2003. Africa in the rise of rights-based development. Geoforum 34: 437-456.
Marcus, G.E. 1995. Ethnography in/of the world system: the emergence of multi-sited ethnography. Annual Review of Anthropology 24: 95-117.
Massé, F., H. Dickinson, J. Margulies, L. Joanny, T. Lappe-Osthege and R. Duffy. 2020. Conservation and crime convergence? Situating the 2018 London illegal wildlife trade conference. Journal of Political Ecology 27: 23-42.
Mayer, B. 2016. Human rights in the Paris Agreement. Climate Law 6: 109-117.
Medina, L.K. 2016. The production of indigenous land rights: judicial decisions across national, regional, and global scales. PoLAR 39(S1): 139-153.
Merlan, F. 2014. Recent rituals of indigenous recognition in Australia: Welcome to Country. American Anthropologist 116(2): 296-309.
Mirosa, O. and L.M. Harris. 2012. Human right to water: contemporary challenges and contours of a global debate. Antipode 44(3): 932-949.
Mohan, G. and K. Stokke. 2000. Participatory development and empowerment: the dangers of localism. Third World Quarterly 21(2): 247-268.
Monfreda, C. 2010. Setting the stage for new global knowledge: science, economics, and indigenous knowledge in the economics of ecosystems and biodiversity at the fourth World Conservation Congress. Conservation and Society 8(4): 276-285.
Murphree, M. 2004. Communal approaches to natural resource management in Africa: from whence and to where. International Journal of Wildlife Law and Policy 7: 203-216.
Neumann, R.P. 2004. Moral and discursive geographies in the war for biodiversity in Africa. Political Geography 23(7): 813-837.
Perera, V. 2014. Engaged universals and community economies: the (human) right to water in Colombia. Antipode 47(1): 197-215.
Radonic, L. 2017. Through the aqueduct and the courts: an analysis of the human right to water and indigenous water rights in northwestern Mexico. Geoforum 84: 151-159.
Ribot, J.C. and N.L. Peluso. 2003. A theory of access. Rural Sociology 68(2): 153-181.
Rodina, L. 2016. Human right to water in Khayelitsha, South Africa - lessons from a 'lived experiences' perspectives. Geoforum 72: 58-66.
Shackleton, C.M., T.J. Willis, K. Brown and N.V.C. Polunin. 2010. Reflecting on the next generation of models for community-based natural resources management. Environmental Conservation 37(1): 1-4.
Shackleton, S., B. Campbell, E. Wollenberg and D. Edmunds. 2002. Devolution and community-based natural resource management: creating space for local people to participate and benefit? Natural Resources Perspectives 76. London: ODI.
Springer, J., J. Campese and M. Painter. 2011. Conservation and human rights: key issues and contexts. Scoping Paper for the Conservation Initiative on Human Rights. Gland, Switzerland: World Wildlife Fund.
Stevens, S. 2014. Indigenous Peoples, national parks, and protected areas: a new paradigm linking conservation, culture, and rights. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
Suárez, S.M. 2013. The human rights framework in contemporary agrarian struggles. The Journal of Peasant Studies 40(1): 239-290.
Suiseeya, K.R.M. 2014. What justice demands: Exploring institutional change in the CBD and the Nagoya protocol on access and benefits sharing. Global Environmental Politics 14(3): 102-124.
Sultana, F. and A. Loftus. 2015. The human right to water: Critiques and condition of possibility. WIREs Water 2: 97-105. doi: 10.1002/wat2.1067.
Sundberg, J. 2014. Decolonizing posthumanist geographies. Cultural Geographies 21(1): 33-47.
Swyngedouw, E. 2003. Globalisation or 'glocalisation'? Networks, territories and re-scaling. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 17(1): 25-48.
Swyngedouw, E. 2005. Governance innovation and the citizen: the Janus face of governance-beyond-the-state. Urban Studies 42(11): 1191-2006.
Tauli-Corpuz, V., J. Alcorn, A. Molnar, C. Healy and E. Barrow. 2020. Cornered by PAs: adopting rights-based approaches to enable cost-effective conservation and climate action. World Development 130. doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2020.104923.
Tsing, A.L. 2015. The mushroom at the end of the world: on the possibility of life in capitalist ruins. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.
Tuck, E. and K.W. Yang. 2012. Decolonization is not a metaphor. Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education and Society 1(1): 1-40.
Western, D. 2001. Taking the broad view of conservation – a response to Adams and Hulme. Oryx 35(3): 201-203.
Witter, R., K.M. Suiseeya, R. Gruby, S. Hitchner, E. Maclin, M. Bourque and J.P. Brosius. 2015. Moments of influence in global environmental governance. Environmental Politics 24(6): 894-912.
Wolmer, W. 2003. Transboundary conservation: the politics of ecological integrity in the great Limpopo transfrontier park. Journal of Southern African Studies 29(1): 261-278.
Wutich, A., M. Beresford and C. Carvajal. 2016. Can informal water vendors deliver on the promise of a human right to water? Results from Cochabamba, Bolivia. World Development 79: 14-24.
Wyatt, S., M. Kessels and F. van Laerhoven. 2015. Indigenous Peoples' expectations for forestry in New Brunswick: are rights enough? Society and Natural Resources 10(1): 625-640.
Yates, J.S. and L.M. Harris. 2018. Hybrid regulatory landscapes: the human right to water, variegated neoliberal water governance, and policy transfer in Cape Town, South Africa, and Accra, Ghana. World Development 110: 75-87.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23621
