Sympathy for Cecil: gender, trophy hunting, and the western environmental imaginary
Abstract
This article draws from political ecology and ecofeminism to examine sympathy, expressed by record-breaking donations from North Americans, for the death of Cecil the Lion. The overlapping normative critique offered by these two perspectives together demonstrates how sympathy is disclosive of power relations. Sympathy reveals, relies upon, and reinforces different forms of gender, racial, and neocolonial domination; especially when western sympathy remains ignorant of the power relations, including their politics and histories, that shape attitudes toward non-human animals and grant them status as members of the (western) moral community.
Keywords: sympathy, ecofeminism, trophy hunting, wildlife conservation, Cecil the Lion
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Adams, C.J. 2000. The sexual politics of meat: a feminist-vegetarian critical theory. New York: Continuum.
Adams, W.M. 2004. Against extinction: the story of conservation. London: Earthscan.
Bauer, H., F. Gebresenbet, M. Kiki, L. Simpson, and C. Sillero-Zubiri. 2019. Race and gender bias in the research community on African lions. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 7(24): 1–4.
Boone and Crockett Club (n.d.). Website. https://www.boone-crockett.org. [accessed May 23, 2018]
Cooper, D.E. 2015. Animals, attitudes and moral theories. In Kidd, I.J. and L. McKinnell (eds.). Science and the self: animals, evolution, and ethics: essays in honour of Mary Midgley. New York: Routledge. Pp. 19–30.
Craven, J. and K. Bellware. 2015. We weep for African lions. But what about black lives? HuffPost, July 30. [accessed June 27, 2019]
Cronon, W. 1995. The trouble with wilderness; or, getting back to the wrong nature. In Cronon, W. (ed.). Uncommon ground: rethinking the human place in nature. New York: Norton & Co. Pp. 69–90.
Cummings, W. 2015. Airlines ban hunters' big-game 'trophies' after uproar over Cecil the Lion. USA Today, August 3. [accessed June 27, 2019]
Curtin, D. 2005. Environmental ethics for a postcolonial world. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Davion, V. 2007. Caring for nature: an ecofeminist's view of Rolston on eating, hunting, and genetics. In Preston, C.J. and W. Ouderkirk (eds.). Nature, value, duty: life on earth with Holmes Rolston, III. Dordrecht: Springer. Pp. 167–181.
Dawson, A. 2016. Extinction: a radical history. New York: OR Books.
Dowie, M. 2009. Conservation refugees: the hundred-year conflict between global conservation and native peoples. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Duffy, R. 2001. Killing for conservation: wildlife policy in Zimbabwe. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
Duffy, R. 2010. Nature crime: how we're getting conservation wrong. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Finney. C. 2014. Black faces, white spaces: reimagining the relationship of African Americans to the great outdoors. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Frank, L.G., R. Woodroffe and M. Ogada. 2005. People and predators in Laikipia District, Kenya. In Woodroffe, R., S. Thirgood, and A. Rabinowitz (eds.). People and wildlife: conflict or coexistence? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Pp. 286–304.
Guha, R. 1989. Radical American environmentalism and wilderness preservation: a third world critique. Environmental Ethics 11(1): 71–83.
Hatkoff, C., J. Hatkoff and I. Hatkoff. 2016. Cecil's pride: the true story of a lion king. New York: Scholastic Press.
Jenkins, N. 2015. Who is really responsible for the killing of Zim's wildlife? The Standard, August 3. [accessed June 27, 2019]
Jimmy Kimmel Live. 2015a. Television broadcast. Episode 98, July 28. American Broadcast Company.
Jimmy Kimmel Live. 2015b. Jimmy Kimmel helps raise $150,000 after Cecil the Lion monologue. ABC. July 30. [accessed July 23, 2019]
Kahn, J. 2018. Should some species be allowed to die out? New York Times, March 13. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/13/magazine/should-some-species-be-allowed-to-die-out.html. [accessed July 9, 2019]
Kalof, L., A. Fitzgerald and L. Baralt. 2004. Animals, women, and weapons: blurred sexual boundaries in the discourse of sport hunting. Society and Animals 12(3): 237–251.
Kheel, M. 2008. Nature ethics: an ecofeminist perspective. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Kim, C.J. 2017. Murder and mattering in Harambe's house. Politics and Animals 3: 1–15.
Kim, C.J. Dangerous crossings: race, species, and nature in a multicultural age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kings, A.E. 2017. Intersectionality and the changing face of ecofeminism. Ethics and the Environment 22(1): 63–87.
Lester, M. 2015. Timeline of Tamir Rice case. New York Times, December 28. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/29/us/tamir-rice-police-shootiing-cleveland.html [accessed July 23, 2019]
Löe, J., and E. Röskaft. 2004. Large carnivores and human safety: a review. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 33(6): 283–288.
Loveridge, A. 2018. Lion hearted: the life and death of Cecil and the future of Africa's iconic cats. New York, NY: Regan Arts.
Macdonald, D.W. 2016. Report on lion conservation with particular respect to the issue of trophy hunting. Report. Oxford: WildCRU.
Macdonald, D.W., K.S. Jacobsen, D. Burnham, P.J. Johnson and A.J. Loveridge. 2016. Cecil: a moment or a movement? Analysis of media coverage of the death of a lion, panthera leo. Animals 6(5): 26.
Macdonald, D.W., P.J. Johnson, A.J. Loveridge, D. Burnham and A.J. Dickman. 2016. Conservation or the moral high ground: siding with Bentham or Kant. Conservation Letters 9(4): 307–8.
Mallory, C. 2018. What's in a name? In defense of ecofeminism (not ecological feminisms, feminist ecology, or gender and the environment): or 'why ecofeminism need not be ecofeminine—but so what if it is?' Ethics and the Environment 23(2): 11–35.
Mellor, M. 1998. Feminism and ecology: an introduction. New York: NYU Press.
Miller, M.E. 2015. Zimbabwe charges farmer over killing of Cecil the Lion, but not American dentist. Washington Post, August 19. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/08/19/zimbabwe-charges-farmer-over-killing-of-cecil-the-lion-but-not-american-dentist [accessed July 1, 2019]
Mitchell, A. 2017. Decolonizing against extinction, part III: white tears and mourning. Worldly (blog), December 14. [accessed April 20, 2020]
Nzo, G. 2015. In Zimbabwe, we don't cry for lions. New York Times, August 5. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/05/opinion/in-zimbabwe-we-dont-cry-for-lions.html [accessed July 9, 2019]
Packer, C., D. Ikanda, B. Kissui and H. Kushnir. 2005. Lion attacks on humans in Tanzania. Nature 436 (7053): 927–928.
Pearce, M. 2018. It took 13 years, two trials and an army of accusers to convict Bill Cosby of one sexual assault. LA Times, September 25. https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-cosby-army-20180925-story.html [accessed July 3, 2019]
Penteriani, V., M. del Mar Delgado, F. Pinchera, J. Naves, A. Fernández-Gil, I. Kojola, S. Härkönen, et al. 2016. Human behaviour can trigger large carnivore attacks in developed countries. Scientific Reports 6 (February).
Plumwood, V. 1993. Feminism and the mastery of nature. London: Routledge.
Plumwood, V. 1995. Human vulnerability and the experience of being prey. Quadrant 39(3): 29–34.
Robbins P. 2012. Political ecology: a critical introduction. 2nd ed. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Saayman, M., P. van der Merwe and A. Saayman. 2018. The economic impact of trophy hunting in the South African wildlife industry. Global Ecology and Conservation 16 (October): 1–9.
Scoones, I. 2015. Why Cecil the lion offers lessons for land reform and the role of elites. The Conversation, August 5. [accessed April 30, 2020]
Somerville, K. 2020. Humans and lions: conflict, conservation, and coexistence. London: Routledge.
Somerville, K. 2017. Cecil the lion in the British media: the pride and prejudice of the press. Journal of African Media Studies 9(3): 471–485.
Spence, M.D. 1999. Dispossessing the wilderness: Indian removal and the making of the national parks. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Spiegel, M. 1996. The dreaded comparison: human and animal slavery. New York: Mirror Books.
Stout, D. 2003. Bush orders sanctions imposed against leaders of Zimbabwe. New York Times, March 8. https://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/08/world/bush-orders-sanctions-imposed-against-leaders-of-zimbabwe.html [accessed July 11, 2019]
The real Teddy Bear story. n.d. Theodore Roosevelt Association. Website. [accessed June 27, 2019]
Thirgood, S., R. Woodroffe and A. Rabinowitz. 2005. The impact of human-wildlife conflict on human lives and livelihoods. In Woodroffe, R., S. Thirgood and A. Rabinowitz. People and wildlife: conflict or coexistence? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Pp. 13–26.
Vira, V. and T. Ewing. 2014. Ivory's curse: the militarization and professionalization of poaching in Africa. C4ADS and Born Free USA.
Walter J Palmer, DDS - Minneapolis, MN. n.d. Yelp. Website. [accessed June 29, 2019]
West, P., J. Igoe and D. Brockington. 2006. Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annual Review of Anthropology 35(1): 251–277.
WildCRU. 2019. WildCRU statement about trophy hunting debate. Oxford: Wildlife Conservation Research Unit. [accessed June 18, 2020]
WildCRU. n.d. Cecil summit. Oxford: Wildlife Conservation Research Unit. [accessed July 11, 2019]
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23526
