"Anishinaabe time": temporalities and impact assessment in pipeline reviews
Abstract
Indigenous ways of living that embrace multiple temporalities have been largely supplanted by a single, linear colonial temporality. Drawing on theoretical insights from Indigenous geographies and political ecology, this article considers how pipeline reviews come into being through contested temporalities and how dominant modes of time dispossess Indigenous peoples of self-determination in energy decision-making. In particular, Anishinaabe clan governance – a form of kinship that provides both social identity and function based on relations to animal nations – is undermined in colonial decision-making processes. Through analysis of documents from Canada's National Energy Board and interviews with Anishinaabe pipeline opponents, I explore tensions between Anishinaabe and settler temporalities reflected in the 2012-2017 Line 9 pipeline dispute in the Great Lakes region. These include divergent understandings of periodicities, timeframes, kinship relations, and the role of nonhuman temporalities in decision-making. Colonial temporal modes that have been imposed on Indigenous communities foreshorten timescales, depoliticize kinship relations, and discount nonhumans in decision-making – resulting in narrower and more short-sighted project reviews than Anishinaabe temporalities would support. I argue that the rich concepts of kinship, queerness, continuity, and prophecy embedded in Anishinaabe temporalities can inform strategies for decolonizing energy review processes and open possibilities for Indigenous self-determination in energy decision-making.
Keywords: Anishinaabe studies, Two-Spirit, Indigenous geographies, temporalities, Indigenous knowledge, energy governance, pipeline, National Energy Board
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Absolon, K.E. 2011. Kaandossiwin: how we come to know. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.
AFN. Written evidence of Aamjiwnaang First Nation; NEB File OF-Fac-Oil-E101-2012-10 02, Document C1-5-1, AFN: 2013.
Anderson, K. 2011. Life stages and Native women: memory, teachings, and story medicine. Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press.
Bebbington, A.J. 2004. Movements and modernizations, markets and municipalities: Indigenous federations in rural Ecuador. In Peet, R. and M.J. Watts (eds.). Liberation ecologies: environment, development, social movements. London: Routledge. Pp. 394-421.
Benton-Banai, E. 1988. The Mishomis book: the voice of the Ojibway. Saint Paul: Red School House.
Benton-Banai, E. 2008. Anishinaabe almanac. M'Chigeeng, ON: Kenjigewin Teg Educational Institute.
Borrows, J. 2002. Recovering Canada: the resurgence of Indigenous law. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Borrows, J. 2012. (Ab)originalism and Canada's constitution. Supreme Court Law Review 58: 351–398.
Borrows, J. and M. Coyle. 2017. The right relationship: reimagining the implementation of historical treaties. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Bowles, P. and H. Veltmeyer. 2014. The answer is still no: voices of pipeline resistance. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.
Brooks, M. 2014. The cautionary tale of Kalamazoo: the still-unfolding horrors of spilled bitumen in Michigan's Kalamazoo River explain why more pipelines are an unacceptable risk. Alternatives Journal 40(1): 22–30.
Burow, P.B., S. Brock and M.R. Dove. 2018. Unsettling the land: indigeneity, ontology, and hybridity in settler colonialism. Environment and Society: Advances in Research 9(1): 57–74.
Carroll, C. 2014. Native enclosures: Tribal National Parks and the progressive politics of environmental stewardship in Indian Country. Geoforum 53: 31–40.
Castree, N. 2009. The spatio-temporality of capitalism. Time and Society 18: 26–61.
Castree, N. 2004. Differential geographies: place, Indigenous rights and 'local' resources. Political Geography 23(2): 133–167.
Cheadle, B. 2016. National Energy Board cites 'apprehension of bias,' drops Energy East reviewers. CTV News 9 September.
Cicciarello-Maher, G. 2017. Decolonizing dialectics. Durham: Duke University Press.
COTTFN. Written evidence of Chippewas of the Thames First Nation; NEB File OF-Fac-Oil-E101-2012-10 02, Document C2-6-3; COTTFN: 2013.
Coombes, B., J.T. Johnson and R. Howitt. 2012. Indigenous geographies I: mere resource conflicts? The complexities in Indigenous land and environmental claims. Progress in Human Geography 36(6): 810-821.
Coombes, B., J.T. Johnson and R. Howitt. 2013. Indigenous geographies II: the aspirational spaces in postcolonial politics – reconciliation, belonging and social. Progress in Human Geography 37(5): 691-700.
Coombes, B., J.T. Johnson and R. Howitt. 2014. Indigenous geographies III: methodological innovation and the unsettling of participatory research. Progress in Human Geography 38(6): 845-854.
Corbiere, M.A. 2013. How do /ni/, /taa/, /se/ and /shin/ alter meanings of Nishinaabekidwinan? In Corbiere, A.O., M.A. Corbiere, D. McGregor and C. Migwans (eds.). Anishinaabewin Niiwin, M'Chigeeng: Ojibwe Cultural Foundation. Pp. 131–140.
Coulthard, G.S. 2014. Red skin, white masks: rejecting the colonial politics of recognition. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Country, B., S. Wright, S. Suchet-Pearson, K. Lloyd, L. Burarrwanga, R. Ganambarr and J. Sweeney. 2016. Co-becoming Bawaka: towards a relational understanding of place/space. Progress in Human Geography 40(4): 455–475.
Cragoe, N.G. 2017. Following the green path: honor the Earth and presentations of Anishinaabe Indigeneity. Wicazo Sa Review 32(2): 46–70.
Daigle, M. 2016. Awawanenitakik: the spatial politics of recognition and relational geographies of Indigenous self-determination. The Canadian Geographer / Le Géographe Canadien 60(2): 259–269.
Davidson-Hunt, I. and F. Berkes. 2003. Learning as you journey: Anishinaabe perception of social-ecological environments and adaptive learning. Ecology and Society 8(1): 5.
Deloria, V.J. 2001. Power and place equal personality. In Deloria, V.J. and D. Wildcat (eds.). Power and place: Indian education in America. Golden, CO: Fulcrum Publishing.
Doerfler, J., N.J. Sinclair and K.H. Stark. 2013. Centering Anishinaabeg studies: understanding the world through stories. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press.
Dokis, C. 2015. Where the rivers meet: pipelines, participatory resource management, and Aboriginal-state relations in the Northwest Territories. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Dumont, J.O. 2015. What was never told. Chippewas of the Thames First Nation.
Enbridge Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Capacity Expansion Project-Enbridge Inc. [accessed on 15 November 2018] https://www.enbridge.com/ECRAI.aspx
Fitz-Henry, E. 2017. Multiple temporalities and the nonhuman Other. Environmental Humanities 9(1): 1–17.
Foster, H. 2017. Another good thing: Ross River Dena Council v. Canada in the Yukon Court of Appeal: or: Indigenous title, presentism; in law and history, and a judge Begbie Puzzle revisited. University of British Columbia Law Review 50(2): 293–320.
Frantz, K. and R. Howitt. 2012. Geography for and with Indigenous peoples: Indigenous geographies as challenge and invitation. GeoJournal 77(6): 727-731.
Geniusz, W.M. 2009. Our knowledge is not primitive: decolonizing botanical Anishinaabe teachings. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
Giniwgiizhig, H.F. 2013. An analysis of traditional Ojibwe civil Chief leadership. Ph.D. dissertation. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota.
Goodin, R. 2009. Temporal justice. Journal of Social Policy 39(1): 1–16.
Government of Canada. 1985. National Energy Board Act. [accessed 16 November 2018] https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/N-7/
Government of Canada. 2018. Bill C-69 (42-1): An Act to Enact the Impact Assessment Act and the Canadian Energy Regulator Act, to amend the Navigation Protection Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts. Parliament of Canada. [accessed 15 November 2018] http://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/42-1/bill/C-69/third-reading
Grant, S. 2014. Securing tar sands circulation: risk, affect, and anticipating the Line 9 reversal. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 32(6): 1019–1035.
Haluza-DeLay, R. and A. Carter. 2014. Joining up and scaling up: analyzing resistance to Canada's "dirty oil". In Bencze, L. and S. Alsop (eds.). Activist science and technology education. Dordrecht: Springer. Pp. 343-362.
Hatfield, S., E. Marino, K.P. Whyte, K.D. Dello and P.W. Mote. 2018. Indian time: time, seasonality, and culture in Traditional Ecological Knowledge of climate change. Ecological Processes 7(1): 25.
Hearne, J. 2017. We all stand side by side: an interview with Elizabeth LaPensée. Studies in American Indian Literatures 29(1): 27–37.
Heyen, N. and L. Van Sant. 2015. Political ecologies of activism and direct action politics. In Perreault, T. A., G. Bridge and J. McCarthy (eds.). The Routledge handbook of political ecology. London: Routledge. Pp. 169-178.
Horn-Miller, K. 2013. What does Indigenous participatory democracy look like? Kahnawa:ke's community decision making process. Review of Constitutional Studies 18(1): 111–133.
Horton, R.A. 2014. To our Anishinaabemowin teachers: we are listening. Rabble. http://rabble.ca/news/2014/02/to-our-anishinaabemowin-teachers-we-are-listening
Huebener, P. 2015. Timing Canada: the shifting politics of time in Canadian literary culture. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Hunsberger, C. and S. Awasis. 2019. Energy justice and Canada's National Energy Board: a critical analysis of the Line 9 pipeline decision. Sustainability 11(3): 783-802.
Igreja, V. 2012. Multiple temporalities in Indigenous justice and healing practices in Mozambique. The International Journal of Transitional Justice 6(3): 404–422.
Iparraguirre, G. 2016. Time, temporality and cultural rhythmics: an anthropological case study. Time and Society 25(3): 613–633.
Irwin, L. 1997. Freedom, law, and prophecy: a brief history of Native American religious resistance. American Indian Quarterly 21(1): 35-55.
Jewell, E.M. 2018. Gimaadaasamin, we are accounting for the People: support for customary governance in Deshkan Ziibiing. Ph.D. dissertation. Victoria, BC: Royal Roads University.
Johnson, J., R. Howitt, G. Cajete, F. Berkes, R. Louis and A. Kliskey. 2016. Weaving Indigenous and sustainability sciences to diversify our methods. Sustainability Science 11(1): 1-11.
Kimmerer, R.W. 2003. Gathering moss: a natural and cultural history of mosses. Corvallis, OR: Oregon State University Press.
Kowal, E. 2015. Time, Indigeneity and white anti-racism in Australia. The Australian Journal of Anthropology 26(1): 94-111.
Kulchyski, P.K. 2013. Aboriginal rights are not human rights: in defence of Indigenous struggles. Winnipeg, MB: Arbeiter Ring Publishing.
LaDuke, W. 2015. The Thunderbirds versus the Black Snake: on Anishinaabe Akiing, an epic battle against oil pipelines is underway. Earth Island Journal 30(3): 44–48.
Larsen, S.C. and J.T. Johnson. 2012. In between worlds: place, experience, and research in Indigenous geography. Journal of Cultural Geography 29(1): 1-13.
Louis, R.P. 2007. Can you hear us now? Voices from the margin: using Indigenous methodologies in geographic research. Geographical Research 45(2): 130–139.
Love, T. and E. Tilley. 2013. Temporal discourse and the news media representation of Indigenous-non-Indigenous relations: a case study from Aotearoa New Zealand. Media International Australia 149(1): 174–188.
McCreary, T. A. and R.A. Milligan. 2013. Pipelines, permits, and protests: Carrier Sekani encounters with the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project. Cultural Geographies 21(1): 115-129.
McGregor, D. 2013. Indigenous women, water justice and Zaagidowin (love). Canadian Woman Studies 30(2–3): 71–79.
MNCFN (Mississaugas of the New Credit First Nation). 2013. Written argument of the Mississaugas of the New Credit First Nation. NEB File OF-FAC-OIL-E101-2012-10 02, Document C3-11-2.
Middleton, B.R. 2015. Jahat Jatitotodom: toward an Indigenous political ecology. In Bryant, R. (ed.). The international handbook of political ecology. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar. Pp. 561–576.
Miller, C. 2013. Every dream is a prophecy: rethinking revitalization – dreams, prophets, and routinized cultural evolution. In Doerfler, J., N.J. Sinclair and H.K. Stark (eds.). Centering Anishinaabeg studies: understanding the world through stories. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press. Pp. 119–132.
Nadasdy, P.E. 2008. Wildlife as renewable resource: competing conceptions of wildlife, time, and management in the Yukon. In Ferry, E.E. and M.E. Limbert (eds.). Timely assets: the politics of resources and their temporalities. Santa Fe: School for Advanced Research Press. Pp. 75-106.
Nelson, M.K. 2013. The hydromythology of the Anishinaabeg. In Doerfler, J., N.J. Sinclair and H.K. Stark (eds.). Centering Anishinaabeg studies: understanding the world through stories. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press. Pp. 213–233.
Ogden, R. 2009. "Existing" Aboriginal rights in Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982. The Canadian Bar Review 88(0): 51–85.
Panelli, R. 2008. Social geographies: encounters with Indigenous and more-than-White/Anglo geographies. Progress in Human Geography 32(6): 801–811.
Pine, D.T. 2016. Ziisabaakodakaan: the place where sugar is made. Masters thesis. Toronto, ON: University of Toronto.
Porter, J. 2017. Northern Ontario First Nations take TransCanada to court over pipeline work. Thunder Bay, ON: CBC News.
Powell, D.E. 2015. The rainbow is our sovereignty: Rethinking the politics of energy on the Navajo Nation. Journal of Political Ecology 22(1): 53-78.
Richotte, K. 2013. Telling all of our stories: reorienting the legal and political events of the Anishinaabeg. In Doerfler, J., N.J. Sinclair and H.K. Stark (eds.). Centering Anishinaabeg studies: understanding the world through stories. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press. Pp. 379–396.
Rifkin, M. 2017. Beyond settler time: temporal sovereignty and Indigenous self-determination. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Robbins, P. 2015. The trickster science. In Perreault, T.A., G. Bridge and J. McCarthy (eds.). The Routledge handbook of political ecology. London: Routledge. Pp. 89-101.
Scott, D.N. 2013. Situating Sarnia: "unimagined communities" in the new national energy debate. Journal of Environmental Law and Practice 25: 81–111.
Simpson, L.B. 2011. Dancing on our turtle's back: stories of Nishnaabeg re-creation, resurgence and a new emergence. Winnipeg, MB: Arbeiter Ring Publishing.
Simpson, L.B. 2017. As we have always done: Indigenous freedom through radical resistance. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Sparks, R. 2017. Ontario First Nations abandon request for emergency stop on TransCanada pipeline work. Toronto, ON: National Observer Media Group.
Supreme Court of Canada. 2017. Chippewas of the Thames First Nation v. Enbridge Pipelines Inc. SCC Cases (Lexum). [accessed 15 November 2018] https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16744/index.do
Sundberg, J. 2003. Conservation and democratization: constituting citizenship in the Maya Biosphere Reserve, Guatemala. Political Geography 22(7): 715–740.
Sundberg, J. 2014. Decolonizing posthumanist geographies. Cultural Geographies 21(1): 33–47.
The Expert Panel on the Modernization of the National Energy Board. 2017. Forward, together: enabling Canada's clean, safe, and secure energy future. Ottawa, ON: Natural Resources Canada.
Unist'ot'en Camp. 2017. Heal the people, heal the land. [accessed 12 March 2020] https://unistoten.camp
Weir, L. 2013. "Time immemorial" and Indigenous rights: a genealogy and three case studies (Calder, Van der Peet, Tsilhqot'in) from British Columbia. Journal of Historical Sociology 26(3): 383–411.
Whyte, K. 2018. Indigenous science (fiction) for the Anthropocene: ancestral dystopias and fantasies of climate crises. Environment and Planning E 1(1): 224-242.
Wilson, S. 2008. Research is ceremony: Indigenous research methods. Halifax, NS: Fernwood Publishing.
Yeh, E. and J. Brayn. 2015. Indigeneity. In Perreault, T.A., G. Bridge and J. McCarthy. (eds.). The Routledge handbook of political ecology. London: Routledge. Pp. 531-544.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23236
